How To Know When You Should Repair Or Replace Your Roof

RCC logo

Is your roof showing signs of wear and tear? Maybe there’s water damage in the attic, or the asphalt shingles are starting to curl at the edges. Or perhaps it has simply outlived its intended lifespan.

Your roof serves as a protective shield for your home against weather elements, but when should you just repair those missing shingles and when is it time for a new roof altogether? Understanding whether to restore or replace your roof can save you from unnecessary costs and ensure that your property remains well-insulated all year round.

In this blog post, we will walk you through key signs that indicate if your roofing system needs minor repairs or a full roof replacement project.

Key Takeaways

Water damage in the upstairs or attic is a clear indication that you may need to repair or replace your roof. This could be caused by leaks and compromised roofing materials.

Understanding the lifespan of your roof is crucial in determining whether it needs minor repairs or a full replacement. Asphalt shingle roofs typically last between 20 to 25 years, but this can be shorter if there was an installation over existing shingles.

A sagging roof is a serious problem that requires immediate attention as it indicates structural damage. It could collapse at any time, risking injury and extensive property damage.

Moss, mold, or mildew growth on your roof signifies potential risks to its integrity and should not be ignored. They can cause granule loss on shingles, retain moisture, and lead to rotting of roofing materials if left untreated.

Signs You Need A New Roof

Water damage in the upstairs or attic indicates the need for a new roof, which can be caused by leaks and poor roof insulation.

Water Damage In The Upstairs Or Attic

Experiencing water damage in the upstairs or attic is a tell-tale sign that your roof may require attention. This could be either from leaks or seepage, often triggered by compromised roofing materials such as aging asphalt shingles.

The manifestation of these issues might not be evident initially but will become apparent with time. Look out for specific signs like moisture marks, brown, yellow, or grey stains on the insides of the roofs indicating unwelcome water infiltration from the external elements.

These stains signal that your roofing system is failing somewhere to resist water intrusion.

Similarly alarming is when you’re able to see daylight peeping through roof boards while inside the attic — an undeniable confession that some parts of your roof have worn thin or cracked open.

A professional examination from a trusted roofing contractor would provide clarity on whether these issues are isolated incidents calling for targeted repairs – perhaps replacing just a few shingles – or harbingers signaling an impending total roof replacement requirement.

The Roof Has Outlived Its Lifespan

Understanding the lifespan of your roof is a crucial factor in determining when it might need to be replaced. Commonly, an asphalt roof and shingle roofs, one of the most common roofing materials used today, have an expected lifespan between 20 to 25 years.

Take a walk around your property with an eye toward spotting any visible signs that may indicate an aging or failing roof – such as curled or cupped edges on your shingles.

Another unmistakable sign comes from bald patches where granules are missing on your roof’s surface.

Be aware that these symptoms could also appear unexpectedly due to other factors such as poor workmanship during initial roof installation or high winds causing damage overtime.

The Roof Sags

One clear sign requiring immediate action is when your roof starts to sag. This isn’t just an aesthetic issue that reduces curb appeal; it’s a severe problem indicating structural damage.

What causes this dreaded droop? Often, it’s due to prolonged exposure to harsh elements such as high winds or heavy snowfall which can excessively burden the roofing materials over time.

Similarly, aging roofs are more prone to this issue as old shingles may not provide sufficient support anymore.

Given how serious these implications are, you should reach out immediately to trusted roofing contractors for a thorough inspection of your entire roof replacement deck condition when you notice even moderate sagging on your existing roof structure.

Moss, Mold, Or Mildew Growth

Moss, mold, or mildew growth on your roof is not just an unsightly issue. It can actually be a clear indicator that you need to take action. As these unwanted guests make themselves at home on your roof, they can speed up the loss of granules on the new shingles and retain moisture, adding unnecessary weight and keeping the roof in constant contact with water.

Discovering mold or mildew growing on walls or ceilings inside your home may also be a sign of a leaky roof or condensation issues caused by trapped moisture. These signs should not be ignored as they indicate that water is making its way through your roof and into your living space.

Remember, moss, mold, and fungi on your roof are more than just cosmetic issues – they signify potential risks to the integrity of your entire roofing system.

Factors To Consider In Repair Vs. Replace Decision

When deciding whether to repair or replace your roof, there are several factors you should consider. The extent of the damage, age of the roof, cost of repairs versus the roof replacement cost alone, and future plans for the property all play a role in making this decision.

By taking these factors into account, you can make an informed choice that will ensure the longevity and safety of your home.

Extent Of Damage

The extent of damage is a fundamental factor to consider when deciding whether to repair or replace your roof. Assessing the level of damage helps determine the most appropriate course of action.

Minor damages, such as a few missing shingles or localized roof leaks, can often be repaired without needing to replace the entire roof.

For instance, if you notice water stains on your ceiling or walls and find evidence of water infiltration in your attic or upstairs rooms, it’s crucial to address these issues promptly.

Similarly, if your roofing materials start deteriorating with age and show signs like curling edges or bald spots on asphalt shingles, it might indicate that they have surpassed their lifespan.

Remember that engaging a trusted roofing contractor for a thorough inspection is essential before making any decisions regarding roof repair versus replacement. Their expertise will help you understand the true extent of damage and provide professional guidance tailored specifically to your situation.

Age Of Roof

The age of your roof is an important factor to consider when deciding whether to repair or replace it. Most roofs have a lifespan depending on the type of material used, and as they age, they become more prone to damage and deterioration.

For example, dimensional asphalt shingle roofs typically last around 27 years.

Understanding the age of your roof is crucial because it helps the roofing companies and contractors determine how to address existing issues and whether a repair or replacement is necessary.

If your roof is nearing the end of its expected lifespan or has surpassed it, repairs may not be enough to ensure its longevity and functionality.

It’s worth noting that various factors can impact the lifespan of a a roofing project, including the type of roofing material used and the climate in which it is installed.

By considering the age of your roof alongside other factors like extent of damage and cost analysis, you’ll be able to make an informed decision about whether repairing or replacing your roof is best for you in terms of both short-term fixes and long-term investment in protecting your home.

Cost Of Repairs Vs. Replacement

When faced with roof damage, homeowners often find themselves weighing the costs of repairs versus a full replacement roof repaired whole. It’s important to carefully consider this decision since it can have long-term financial implications.

Generally, repairing a roof is less expensive and quicker than replacing it entirely. If the damage is isolated to just a few shingles or there are minor leaks, then repair might be the most cost-effective option.

Another key consideration is that restoring or repairing a problematic roof may initially seem like an affordable choice, but when you factor in recurring repair costs and potential future damages caused by underlying issues, ultimately replacing your roof could save you money in the long term.

It’s worth mentioning that according to Angi’s data, average roofing replacement costs around $9 000 with prices ranging from $5 700 up to $12 500. While this investment might appear high upfront compared to repairs which can cost several hundred dollars for minor fixes; a new top roofing company offers durability and peace of mind knowing you won’t face frequent maintenance expenses down the line.

Future Plans For The Property

Considering your future plans for the property is an important factor to take into account when deciding whether to repair or replace your roof. If you plan on selling the property in the near future, investing in a new roof can significantly increase its value and curb appeal.

On the other hand, if you plan on staying in your current home for many years to come, repairing the roof may be a more practical solution. However, you should always consider the overall condition of the roof and weigh it against any long-term plans you may have for renovations or additions to your property.

Ultimately, whether you choose to repair or replace your roof depends on several factors such as budget constraints, time considerations, and personal preferences. Consulting with a trusted, professional roofing company or contractor can provide valuable insights into what options are best suited for your specific situation.

By carefully considering both immediate needs and long-term goals for your property, you’ll be able to determine whether repairing or replacing your roof is the right choice for maintaining its integrity and protecting its value over time.


In conclusion, knowing when to repair or replace your roof is crucial for maintaining the safety and integrity of your home. By paying attention to signs such as water damage, sagging, moss growth, and the age of your roof, you can make an informed decision full roof replacement.

Regular under roof repairs and inspections are highly recommended by experts in order to catch any issues early on.

An very old roof, or visibly damaged roof can compromise not only its functionality but also the aesthetic appeal and value of your property.

Remember that asphalt roofs generally last around 15 years.

When making the repair versus repair or replace roof decision, consider consulting with trusted roofing contractors who can provide professional advice based on thorough inspections.

Taking proactive measures now to address roofing problems can save you from costly repairs down the road.

If you’d like a professional to do it for you, contact Rankin County Custom. They offer free and same-day evaluations, 24/7 emergency services, and are GAF Master Elite.

Contact RCC Roofing & Construction
  • Please enter your first name.
  • Please enter your last name.
  • Please enter your phone number.
    This isn't a valid phone number.
  • Please enter your email address.
    This isn't a valid email address.
  • Please lookup your address.
  • Please make a selection.
  • Please enter a message.
  • By submitting, you agree to be contacted about your request & other information using automated technology. Message frequency varies. Msg & data rates may apply. Text STOP to cancel. Acceptable Use Policy

Why Choose RCC Roofing & Construction?

  • Innovation

    We stay up to date on the newest techniques, consistently pioneering new strategies to provide the best service.

  • Trust

    With almost 20 years of experience, we have developed a respected reputation as a trusted business in the community.

  • Transparency

    At RCC, we lead with honesty; we'll keep you up date to at every step and operate with transparency.

  • Education

    We help you understand the full scope of your project so that you can make the best choices for your home.